Comments on: CLANNAD ~After Story~ 24 [END]

By: Roy Mustang

Roy Mustang — Tue, 07 Apr 2009 12:57:40 +0000

Anyway, concerning the Kanon vs. Clannad thing.

The comedy of Clannad destroyed the comedy of Kanon. And the drama of After Story destroyed the drama of Kanon. It’s like comparing Special Jam-u with Super Hyper Rainbow Pan with Special Jam-u. There is no comparision.

By: Roy Mustang

Roy Mustang — Tue, 07 Apr 2009 11:03:58 +0000

>>>Got my f*cking picnic scene, but nobody’s even there. O_O

A Fuko/Ushio loli harem ending is fine too.

By: Some guy

Some guy — Tue, 07 Apr 2009 07:33:16 +0000

Aye. School Life Clannad was pretty great…

Air, though, didn’t do too much for me. Only around the end did it get interesting at all…Kanna arc was okay, though.

By: Shirukii

Shirukii — Tue, 07 Apr 2009 04:31:05 +0000

@ Some Guy: I suppose, but I was really hoping to see more of the pre-tragedy stuff. While I was clamoring for tragedy when harem/comedy was prevalent, the massive overdose of drama at the end left me longing for the upbeat times of old.

@ CherryNova: Yep, unless they do a Tomoyo After o_o

@ Roy Mustang: More like recap half series, amirite? I still loved AIR though, end made me BAAAAW.

By: Roy Mustang

Roy Mustang — Tue, 07 Apr 2009 03:58:40 +0000

>>>>I hate you. Recap episode + 30 seconds of “new” footage a finale does not make.

It was 100X better than AIR’s recap episode. I hope I didn’t spoil anything for you.

By: Gar

Gar — Mon, 06 Apr 2009 04:25:41 +0000

@CherryNova: I would imagine so, unless they decide to make Tomoyo After…but they already gave her an OVA, so who knows?

@Jay: I agree completely about Kanon being better than Clannad. I really liked Clannad, but I don’t think it can really compete with Kanon when it comes to sad moments….

By: CherryNova

CherryNova — Mon, 06 Apr 2009 01:49:13 +0000

So are all clannad related animes finished?

By: Some guy

Some guy — Sun, 05 Apr 2009 21:44:53 +0000

I’ll disagree. I liked the recap, it brought back a lot of old memories of the show. The way they fit it as a frame story, with Tomoya actually telling it, was a nice way to actually fit the recap within the story (and give us an excuse for more Ushio). The new footage brought a smile to my face, too. Nagisa calling Fuko “Fu-chan” made me particularly happy.

As for final thoughts, the whole series has been really uplifting. I started watching Clannad late, to the point where I started just as the first season ended. I marathoned it within a week and it was probably the best thing I had watched up to that point. I went through a rush of emotions, be it happiness or rage or empathy for all of the cast’s troubles. I fit Air in while I was waiting for Afterstory, and while I liked Air, it didn’t seem to compare to all that I had felt watching Clannad.

When Afterstory came along, I was happy to enjoy for what it was — a continuation of School Life. It was lighthearted and made me laugh. Each successive arc, even though it may not have had any actual significance to the main story, really made the characters for me. That was important to me. While the story was great, though sometimes heavy handed, what really pulled me in was how much I could empathize with the characters.

Clannad Afterstory brought me extremely close to tears at plenty of points. I shed some at Nagisa’s death out of how much I felt sorry for Tomoya, to lose his wife for this great sacrifice. I shed some at the field of flowers, when Tomoya finally became a dad. I shed some in the contrasting snow, when Tomoya’s fatherhood took an abrupt and tragic end. Then I shed even more in the final episode, where all the troubles and emotions I went through culminated in the best ending the series could have.

Clannad is great.